All The Protein Pumpkin Pie


Have you made it? Protein Pumpkin Pie? It’s delicious! A lot like ‘real’ pumpkin pie. Actually better, I think! Because it doesn’t fill you up to the point of rendering you immobile if you eat a lot of it, hehe :-)

There are several different ways of making Pumpkin Protein Pie. I’ve published quite a few recipes, like this one, this one, and the one found in this post here. I’ve even created a recipe for Pumpkin Protein Pie Bread. Unusual, I know, but really tasty! Check it out.

My favorite kind of Protein Pumpkin Pie though has got to be my crustless protein pumpkin pie. Why? Because it’s unbelievably easy and delicious! It’s also crustless which means it’s really quick to make and completely fuss-free.

I actually created this recipe for Thanksgiving last year, in what turned out being only a couple of days before I had my baby! It was PERFECT timing because I ended up having a slice of protein pumpkin pie the first few weeks post-pregnancy when there was little time to cook. I was so grateful for it! Because not only was it delicious; it was also really nutritious too, you know? Packed full of vitamin C, fiber, and protein!

Below is that recipe. You can find it in the Protein Pow App too! I”m making it again this year (will post a photo on Friday).

Note: If you’d like to add a crust to your pie, you can do that too. I made a version of it with a crust that was just ground almonds (about ½ cup) mixed with ¼ cup of honey/agave, 1 big tbsp of melted coconut oil, and 1/8 cup of almond milk, pressed together onto a non-stick pan and baked for 20 minutes at 170 C (around 335 F) before adding the pie filling to it and baking it as per the directions below (check out where I posted a pic of the crust).

Ingredients (for two 9-inch pies)

2 cans (425g each) of canned pumpkin puree
½ cup vanilla (or unflavored) whey protein powder
2 large whole eggs
½ cup coconut sugar
½ tbp pumpkin spice
1 tbsp maple extract (optional but lovely!)


1. Blend all ingredients together
2. Divide into two 9-inch silicone non-stick pans (I say silicone because they’re far easier to unmold and bake that way. If you don’t have any silicone bakeware by the way, now’s your chance to add it to your holiday wish-list!)
3. Bake at 170 C (around 335 F) for 35-45 minutes – just keep an eye on it and remove it from the oven as soon as your knife is clean after you poke the pie with it.
4. Let it cool completely before unmolding and slicing.

Macros per slice (out of 16 – so, 8 slices per pie): 60kcals, 4g protein, 8g carbs (out of which 2g is fiber!) and 1g fat.

Protein Pow


Leave a Comment

Check out our POWerful ingredients!

All you need to make your own delicious protein bars, protein pancakes, cookies, cakes, pizza crusts, and more!